PremiumBuy this article or read it with a Substack subscription.See options

Why the “right” approach depends on how you measure it

If you are a quant, you probably know that trend following is one of the most straightforward quantitative styles for trading markets.

Every signal family within the trend-factor umbrella is, at its core, a different way of determining whether an asset is going up or down, and then betting on the persistence of that behavior.

No amount of mathematical sophistication or complex modeling changes the fact that the time-series momentum effect is the main PnL driver for any trend-following portfolio manager. One might therefore expect that different versions of fundamentally similar signals, all harvesting the same market effect, would lead trend managers to achieve rather similar, homogeneous results.

The data tells a very different story.

In practice, the signal component is really just step zero. What ultimately determines a trend-following program’s outcome isn’t just the signal itself, it’s the dozens of decisions layered on top of it:

Each layer compounds on the last, and over time, these choices cause managers to drift substantially from one another.

This phenomenon is commonly referred to by practitioners as trend-follower dispersion. It is what causes two highly successful trend managers, such as Mulvaney, which runs at a historical volatility of approximately 40%, and Quantica (which operates at a fraction of that volatility) to be placed in the same broad category despite delivering markedly different return profiles.

Notably, Quantica has maintained its relatively low volatility with great consistency over the past 20 years (as shown in the picture below), while Mulvaney’s realized volatility has exhibited considerably wider swings around its long-run average.

In our experience building trend-following programs, both for our own portfolios and for external clients, position sizing is one of the most impactful decisions a manager can make.

Whether driven by mandate restrictions, VaR requirements, or the deliberate construction of a high-volatility trend sleeve, the same signal applied to the same universe of futures can give rise to very different outcomes.

Drawing inspiration from a piece we published in 2025 (link), we revisit the question:

What is the best approach to position sizing?

As we will show with a simple case study, the answer is more nuanced than one might expect.


The Strategy

Buy/Sell Engine

Although our focus today isn’t on the buy/sell engine itself, this is a good opportunity to introduce an entry/exit signal model we haven’t covered in our previous articles.

Premium article

Read the full article

Buy this article on its own, or subscribe on Substack to read it together with all our premium research.

This article

$80.00 one-time

The full 12-page article as a PDF, emailed to you right after payment. Yours to keep.

Buy for $80.00

Secure checkout with Stripe

All premium articles

Substack subscription

This article plus every other premium article, backtest and trading strategy we publish.

Subscribe on Substack

Concretum Research on Substack

Questions about buying or your order? Email [email protected]

Get research like this before it’s public.

Enter your email to receive our next data-driven analysis.