Testing Alternative Entry Policies in a S&P500 Mean-Reversion Model
If we had to name the single investing motto that has defined the last fifteen years, it would be “BUY THE DIP!”
Whether driven by central-bank support, structural inflows, or investor psychology, market participants have become increasingly conditioned to treat short-term weakness as an opportunity rather than a threat.
Yet one surprisingly practical question receives far less attention:
How should the dip actually be bought?
Should traders buy immediately after the signal appears? Wait until the next session? Or demand a deeper selloff before committing capital?
In this article, we revisit one of the best-known mean-reversion concepts in quantitative trading and compare several execution policies across more than 70,000 pullback trades in S&P 500 stocks between January 2010 and May 2026.
While the underlying signal remains identical throughout the study, we find that average profitability varies dramatically depending solely on how positions are entered, ranging from roughly 30 basis points to nearly 180 basis points per trade.
More importantly, the results suggest that there is no universally optimal entry policy. The preferred execution method ultimately depends on the role the strategy is expected to play within a broader portfolio.
For an investor seeking a small number of high-conviction opportunities, a highly selective entry policy may be preferable. For a manager building a dedicated mean-reversion portfolio, however, the ability to generate enough trades to keep capital consistently deployed may matter more than maximizing expectancy on every individual position.
Premium article
Read the full article
Buy this article on its own, or subscribe on Substack to read it together with all our premium research.
Questions about buying or your order? Email [email protected]
