An Intraday Trend Case Study
If you have ever read trading books or browsed online material on technical analysis, chances are you have also come across the concept of price patterns.
Regardless of how they are presented (sometimes as the holy grail, sometimes through more honest analysis), they stand as some of the most popular tools in short-term trading, especially among retail traders, both discretionary and systematic.
What we have found over the years, unfortunately, is that a great deal of misconception surrounds price patterns, not only in how practitioners think about them in the first place, but also in how they should be studied and evaluated. Left unaddressed, these misconceptions can easily mislead traders into using price patterns in unreliable and methodologically incorrect ways.
Our recent piece showing an opening range breakout (ORB) strategy applied to SPY offers a good occasion to revisit this topic properly.
If you wish to read the full details behind the rules and the way we approached the construction of an ORB strategy on SPY, the piece is available below.
Whether you have spent some time studying price patterns or are entirely new to the concept, we think the considerations that follow could save you some costly mistakes in your future trading.
The Mother of All Sins
First and foremost, perhaps the largest misconception of all is to treat price patterns as “magical” indicators that, by virtue of their specific construction, carry special predictive content about the subsequent direction of prices.
A quick look through online trading forums makes our point more clear. It is not hard to find an army of traders willing to die on the hill that the “Triple Reversal Thrust” is the key to successful short-term trading, while an equally passionate army insists that only its slightly modified cousin, the “Inverted Triple Reversal Thrust”, is the one reliable pattern worth using.
Needless to say, this mental model reveals a lack of first-principles thinking about what price patterns truly represent. Once we strip away the evocative names and the layered conditions, we should ask ourselves:
What market behavior is this pattern actually trying to capture?
Seen through that lens, price patterns are (just like every other canonical family of “indicators”) an attempt to model and abstract specific price dynamics that should, in theory, be informative about future price moves. The rules, conditions and details that define a given pattern are nothing more than alternative specifications of the same underlying behavior being modelled, whatever that behavior happens to be.
So, for example, if you are told that the “Three Black Crows” formation is the go-to signal for catching reversals in stocks, and you then hear someone else insist that you should instead wait for two consecutive “Dragonfly Dojis”, be aware that both are really just different ways of modeling short-term mean reversion. Provided they both work, it is not thanks to their special combinations of rules, but because of the same underlying price anomaly that both are trying to capture.
Seen this way, the merit of a pattern should not be judged by its specification, but rather by how simply, elegantly and effectively it captures an underlying market effect.
This also means that if we lack the ability to understand the economic rationale behind a price-pattern specification, then we should not use it. Even when a backtest shows that filtering trades on such a pattern is beneficial, the fact that we cannot trace that improvement back to a precise anomaly makes relying on it a weak choice.
Now that we have established that price patterns do not derive their claimed effectiveness from some special combination of rules, let us look at how to evaluate the effectiveness of classic compression-expansion patterns within an intraday trend framework.
Our Case Study
Following on from our previous ORB study, we now examine a set of daily price patterns (each observable at the close of session t−1) that may reflect differing states of price compression or expansion.
We considered eight patterns in total, evenly divided into four expansion-type and four compression-type, drawn or adapted from widely influential technical analysis sources such as Toby Crabel’s Day Trading with Short Term Price Patterns and Opening Range Breakout and Connors & Raschke’s Street Smarts.
Premium article
Read the full article
Buy this article on its own, or subscribe on Substack to read it together with all our premium research.
Questions about buying or your order? Email [email protected]
